Why you can’t decide whether to stay or go in your relationship - and why it’s so hard.

If you've been finding yourself lying awake going over the same question you've been going over every night for months now, this is for you.
The question of whether to stay or go can be excruciatingly hard to navigate.
I know it took me about 2 years in my own situation - and I was exhausted. Sleepless nights, feeling unfocused at work, staring at my phone writing and rewriting texts, tension, panic, fatigue...it was awful.
Maybe there's someone else in the picture, which makes it even more complicated. Maybe they’re applying pressure and have started asking what you're waiting for. Maybe you’re just not happy and walking around on eggshells at home, but you can’t stomach the idea of leaving.
Either way, the question keeps percolating in your mind, and you don’t seem to be getting any closer to a decision.
In a way it’s strange for you, because at work you decide in minutes.
You've hired, fired, bought companies and walked away from deals worth millions. You trust your judgement everywhere else.
So why is this so hard? Why are you so paralysed?
Given how common this is in my work, I decided to look into decades of decision research to help explain exactly why this choice is so difficult - and why it can feel almost impossible, even for the most talented and intelligent person.
WHY INDECISION IS SO EASY TO FALL INTO
1. Doing nothing feels safest.
Sometimes it feels safer to do nothing at all.
Economists William Samuelson and Richard Zeckhauser (1988) named it status quo bias - we favour the current path, even when it serves us poorly. Psychologists Ilana Ritov and Jonathan Baron (1990) found something similar, which they called the omission bias. We judge harm caused by acting as worse than harm caused by not acting.
In other words, leaving feels like a choice you would have to own, while staying stuck feels like nothing at all.
So you become more passive and it feels a lot safer. You’re not hurting anyone directly, and you’re less of an active decision maker.
But this is an illusion. Because doing nothing is still a choice. It just looks much more subtle and insidious.
Every month you wait is a month you've chosen to delay action, without ever deciding.
People are getting older, situations are getting more entrenched, and your own life is passing you by (as is your partner's) and you are still making a decision, even if it doesn’t feel like it. You are.
How confident are you really, that doing nothing is safer? I invite you to reconsider that.
2. Hard trade-offs make us not want to choose at all.
When the future looks bleak and the idea of leaving is scary, then you're less likely to want to choose at all.
Amos Tversky and Eldar Shafir (1992) found that when every option carries a real cost, people are more likely to put off choosing altogether, even when waiting also causes harm (as I note above).
If you believe that you are stuck between two tough options then you’re not likely going to want to choose either of them.
Stay, and you don’t get to be the liberated version of yourself that you are with the other person. You also don’t get to experience the new, to grow and to have a different life.
If you go, you lose the family as it is. The future is uncertain (whereas staying feels more familiar) and you don’t know what lies ahead. The possibility of freedom is there, but what will it look like? It’s scary to envision without more certainty.
Neither of the two paths is clean, so the mind keeps both doors open and stalls by avoiding walking through either of them.
Some call it analysis paralysis, when it becomes so hard to know which option is the best one.
3. You already have sunk costs
You've come this far into your marriage, you don't want to lose all the investment you've made.
Hal Arkes and Catherine Blumer (1985) showed how strongly past investment shapes present decisions.
With your partner you’ve had twenty years, a house, kids, a whole history. These feel like reasons to stay, and reasons you can't possibly leave.
The sunk cost is what’s keeping you here - you can’t imagine all of this going to ‘waste’..
Meanwhile the question that really matters - whether your marriage is built for this next state of life and what you really want - starts to get drowned out by the fear of losing what you’ve built.
It’s fear again, keeping you stuck clinging to the old, afraid of losing it in exchange for the new.
WHY ACTING FEELS SO HARD
4. Losses feel twice as heavy as gains.
The brain fixates on what you lose, rather than what you gain.
Interestingly, Daniel Kaheman and Amos Tversky's research on loss aversion found that losses weigh roughly twice as much as equal gains.
Your mind counts what you'd lose at double weight. So, the house, all those family routines, your typical Sunday morning - all of these pieces feel ultra painful to let go of.
Whereas what you might gain barely registers as anything to consider.
You focus on the negative, and can’t even imagine the positive.
5. We overestimate how bad the hard thing will feel.
Leaving feels petrifying.
Daniel Gilbert, Timothy Wilson and colleagues (1998) found that people consistently overestimate how intensely and how long a painful event will hurt.
This is super relevant to you because you underestimate your own capacity to adapt and recover.
So the conversation you dread looms far, far larger in your imagination than it will in life.
The fear of the moment keeps you stuck in a fantasy obsessing over how hard that moment will be, as opposed to living the moment and realising it isn’t half as bad as you imagined it to be.
WHY YOU CAN'T SEE IT CLEARLY ALONE
6. You're wiser about every life except your own.
It's easy to have perspective with other people, but incredibly hard with your own life.
Igor Grossmann and Ethan Kross (2014) found that people reason more wisely about a friend's dilemma than about their own. Distance brings perspective, and inside your own marriage you don’t have distance because you are stuck within it. Researchers call this Solomon's paradox.
This is why you can give a friend clear advice about his marriage and it comes so easily, but can't seem to give yourself any good advice at all.
Kross and colleagues (2014) also found that even small acts of stepping back helped people stay calmer and reason more clearly under stress. One example was thinking about your situation using your own name rather than "I."
E.g. Paul wants to tell his wife he is leaving her but he is scared to.
Distance, it turns out, is something you can create for yourself without having to actually go anywhere.
7. Thinking harder starts to make you go in circles
Rumination is a vicious, horrible thing that keeps you stuck looping over and over again.
Psychologist Susan Nolen-Hoeksema's research on rumination showed that repetitive, private dwelling on a problem tends to deepen distress and weaken problem-solving.
This is why the spreadsheet, the 3am pros and cons, all those conversations rehearsed in the car can feel like work but they are just your mind fixating on the loop itself.
You think you’re getting closer to solving the problem but really you’re just going in circles, getting more and more entangled.
THE COST OF WAITING
What’s interesting is that Thomas Gilovich and Victoria Medvec (1995) found that in the short term, people regret the things they did but over the long term, they regret the things they didn't do.
Which means that indecision can feel like protection, but over time, it becomes the thing you end up regretting.
And if you were to really look at your situation, you’d see that it costs you even now.
All that sleep you don't get because you’re ruminating, the focus you lose in meetings because you’re tired and distracted - that’s all part of it. The way you’re so anxious when you’re with the kids, and the stress from having to navigate two lives, keeping it all together - it’s adding up.
WHAT CHANGES WITH DISTANCE
So all of this means that this decision is built to be really, really difficult when you face it alone.
Clearly, clarity rarely comes from thinking harder.
Rather, it comes from having distance. Which you can gain from taking on a calm, outside perspective from someone that has no stakes in your answer, and can see what you can't from the inside. This won’t be a family member or friend as they typically have their own bias - you need someone neutral who really has nothing to gain from either direction.
Once you have that perspective, the loop breaks.
You get to finally stop rehearsing conversations in the car and you can finally close the spreadsheet because you no longer need it to tell you what you already know deep down. You get to look honestly at what your marriage could become, and what it can't, from a neutral, balanced viewpoint.
Some people find the marriage they'd written off still has life in it, and they choose it again with their eyes open, choosing to act differently. Whereas some realise that it's over, and leave with care, in a way their children can understand. Some end the other relationship and finally come home fully, bringing their real selves back into their marriage.
Each of those can be a good outcome. What they share is that the person made the choice, instead of letting time make it for them.
You really can sleep through the night, and walk through your front door knowing exactly why you're there. Your kids CAN get all of you, and you can bring your real self back home.
Whatever you choose, you can choose it with both eyes open. And you can live with it.
If you've been navigating this indecision for months, write me. Tell me as much or as little as you like. Everything stays between us.



Comments